Loan File Review

ID Status Date Public/Private Industry AHACPA Contact
#6747 Closed public FHA Lender
Customer Reply

I have a two questions on sampling of lender loan files for compliance.

1. The HUD audit guide is not clear on selection, i.e. should we select samples from only FHA insured loans or from the lender’s entire portfolio of underwritten loans for the year?

2. If we should select samples from the entire pool of loans underwritten during the year, are there specific samples sizes for FHA underwritten loans and conventional?

Kathy Christensen

From Les Sparks:

The HUD Audit Guide only applies to FHA insured loans. Therefore, your sample should be selected from FHA insured loans. That being said, because of CFPB and the Yellow Book I believe you also are a responsibility to test some non FHA insured loans.

For your second question, here is a copy of a our FHA Lender training that should help answer you question.

Appropriate for populations of greater > 250

Significance of Control and Inherent Risk
of Compliance Requirement Minimum Sample
0 deviations expected: Size

Very significant and higher inherent risk 60
Very significant and limited inherent risk 40


Moderately significant and higher inherent risk
Moderately significant and limited inherent risk 25

Based on the above chart, chances are 25 may not be enough for your testing.


Write a reply

The ticket has been closed. If you feel that your issue has not been solved yet or something new came up in relation to this ticket, you can re-open it by clicking this link.
Item Status Opt-in Date Opt-out Date Action
Additional Information